To excel in coaching and leadership—teaching rather than punishing—tact is essential. Often, how we deliver feedback matters as much as what we say.
Related: 10 Traits of an Effective Teacher
This piece explores the art of effective discipline.
In his book The Wood: A Lifetime of Observations and Reflections On and Off the Court with Steve Jamison, Coach John Wooden shares a memorable story about disciplining his star UCLA center, Bill Walton.
"There was a rule against facial hair for players on UCLA basketball teams. One day, after a 10-day break, Bill Walton showed up for practice with a beard. I asked him, 'Bill, did you miss anything?'
"He said, 'Coach, if you mean the beard, I think I should be allowed to wear it. It's my right.'
"I asked, 'Do you firmly believe in this?' He replied, 'Yeah, I think so, Coach. A lot.'
"I looked at him and said politely, 'Bill, I have great respect for people who stand up for the things they believe in. I really do. And the team will miss you.'
"Bill went to the locker room and shaved his beard before practice started. There were no hard feelings. I wasn't mad, and he wasn't mad. The key principle Coach Wooden followed? He addressed Walton's action, not his character or intent.
Related: 8 Key Elements of a Good Working Relationship
If an employee is repeatedly late, avoid saying, 'You've been late three times in the last two weeks. It's so irresponsible. Don't you even care about your job?' That attacks character and intent.
Discipline rooted in shame, guilt, or fear weakens people. Discipline grounded in reason teaches and strengthens them.
A better approach: 'You've been late three times in the past two weeks. I know you don't mean to be late; however, our business requires punctuality. What's causing this?' This focuses on the action, leaving character and intent untouched.
Discipline that uses shame, guilt, or fear weakens people. A discipline that uses reason teaches and improves them.
Coach Wooden outlined these principles in his essay 'How to Avoid Grievances.' Mastering the art of constructive criticism yields positive results. Follow these proven rules:
1. Get all the facts. Only then can you assess fairly. Ask, 'What happened?' Focus on what went wrong, not who to blame.
2. Keep calm. Create a collaborative climate: 'Let's solve this together'—you and the person versus the problem. They'll respond positively.
3. Criticize privately. Research consistently shows private feedback outperforms public shaming.
Praise first, then critique, and end with encouragement. This softens the message, affirms respect, and frames the error as a one-off against their usual strong performance—helping them save face.
Keep criticism constructive: Teach better ways forward. Collaborate on causes and prevention for lasting improvement.
Related: How to Set a Good Example
